Colorado Notable Arrest Records
A famous booking photo is only the start of a paper trail. The table points to a record path rather than a picture collection. Match the image to the court file and the agency that made the arrest. Draw no conclusion before that. When an appeal or a pending prosecution came later, that later status matters. It carries as much weight as the original charge.
| Case | Arrest or Case Year | Disposition or Current Status | Primary Record Path |
|---|---|---|---|
| James Holmes | 2012 | 2015 jury convictions; 12 life terms plus 3,318 years. | Aurora/Arapahoe agency records and district court file. |
| Christopher Watts | 2018 | Guilty plea; three consecutive life terms plus additional time. | Weld District Court 18CR2003 and Weld Sheriff. |
| Anderson Lee Aldrich | 2022 | Federal guilty plea; 55 concurrent life sentences consecutive to 190 years. | EPSO record, federal docket, then BOP custody locator. |
| Richard Holzer | 2019 | Federal guilty plea; 235 months and supervised release. | U.S. District Court and federal custody record. |
| Mark Redwine | 2017 | 2021 conviction affirmed on appeal in April 2026. | La Plata Sheriff/DA and District Court 17CR343. |
| Tina Peters | 2022 | Convictions affirmed; sentence reversed and remanded in 2026. | Mesa County case 22CR371 and Court of Appeals 2026COA24. |
| Barry Morphew | 2021; reindicted 2025 | First case dismissed without prejudice; current case pending as of September 22, 2026. | Chaffee booking record and Alamosa case 2025CR128. |
| Letecia Stauch | 2020 | 2023 conviction reversed and remanded for a new trial in 2026. | El Paso County case 20CR1358 and Court of Appeals 2026COA22. |
No summary table can stand in for the live docket. Court events often change after a news story or booking photo appears, so confirm the latest order before repeating a case's status.
Colorado Holmes Case Records
The July 20, 2012 theater shooting put James Holmes in custody. Aurora Police made the arrest. Warrant materials trace his processing through the Aurora City Jail. Arapahoe County District Court heard the criminal case. In 2015 a jury convicted him on murder, attempted-murder, explosives, and weapons counts. The punishment: 12 consecutive life terms without parole plus 3,318 years. His booking image belongs to the law-enforcement custody record. The verdict and sentence rest entirely in the court file and final judgment. The published search-warrant record shows the processing path. Court and news records document the outcome. A later news image is never the originating photo file. Request the true record from the proper agency. Then match it to the final court disposition. Any famous image should be traced to both the booking custodian and the court. Do not treat it as the whole case history.
Colorado Watts Court Disposition
Christopher Watts was arrested in 2018. The arrest followed a Weld County investigation into the deaths of Shanann, Bella, and Celeste Watts. The court path is Weld County District Court case 18CR2003. In November 2018 Watts pleaded guilty to all nine counts. Those counts included murder, unlawful termination of pregnancy, and tampering with a deceased human body. He got three consecutive life sentences without parole, plus additional consecutive time. The Weld County District Attorney's plea release records the outcome. The Weld Daily Arrest system offers only a historical text search. It shows no public booking photo. The original booking image stays with the Weld County Sheriff. It is available by request under the CCJRA. News reproductions are secondary copies. They can omit the plea or the sentence. For other Weld bookings, start with the county arrest lookup. Then check the court docket for the outcome.
Colorado Aldrich Federal Case
Aldrich's booking started as a county matter. The El Paso County Sheriff's Office said its tactical team took Anderson Lee Aldrich into custody after a standoff and negotiation following the 2022 Club Q shooting. The booking record sits at the county level. The case then moved to federal court. He pleaded guilty to 74 hate-crime and firearms counts. The U.S. Attorney's Office reported the punishment: 55 concurrent life sentences plus a consecutive 190 years.
Two documents carry the case. The EPSO statement covers the local arrest, and the Department of Justice sentencing release covers the federal outcome. The federal BOP locator can show custody fields once an inmate is committed, but it publishes no public mugshot. For the sentence, use the federal judgment; for the photo, ask EPSO for the original county image. That path separates a local busted-record entry from the later federal prosecution and federal custody.
Colorado Holzer Federal Record
Richard Holzer's case never touched a county jail. The FBI arrested him in 2019 after he accepted inert explosive devices from undercover agents during a Pueblo-area operation. Federal papers tell that story. The complaint and judgment are the primary prosecution record. Holzer pleaded guilty to federal hate-crime and explosives charges. The sentence came to 235 months, more than 19 years, followed by 15 years of supervised release.
The Department of Justice sentencing release states the federal outcome. Colorado Public Radio's case report used an image credited to the El Paso County Sheriff's Office. That photo is a republication. It is not the original federal or county record. Which agency holds the image decides where a photo request goes, while the court judgment settles the sentence. A story's photo credit can point to a different custodian than the sentencing court, as this Colorado case shows.
Colorado Redwine Appeal Record
Mark Redwine's record spans years, not one arrest. A 2017 indictment in the death of Dylan Redwine led to his arrest. In 2021, a La Plata County jury convicted him of second-degree murder and child abuse resulting in death. The case did not end there. The Colorado Court of Appeals later weighed in. Its April 2026 disposition list shows the judgment affirmed in La Plata County District Court case 17CR343.
The Colorado Judicial Branch disposition gives the later status. The La Plata County Sheriff and District Attorney hold the original local records. Use both together. An appellate result and a trial judgment describe a case more fully than any booking-era caption or older news article. For an older arrest image, request the source agency's copy and confirm the court history separately.
Colorado Peters Resentencing Status
Tina Peters landed in a Mesa County jail after her arrest over election equipment. In August 2024, a jury convicted her on seven counts. Four were felonies. The trial court handed down nine years in October 2024. Then came the appeal. In 2026COA24, the Colorado Court of Appeals upheld the convictions but reversed the sentence. The judge had weighed protected speech improperly. That error sent the case back for a new sentencing hearing. The 2026 appellate opinion carries that full story. Mesa County Sheriff holds the booking record. Mesa County District Court case 22CR371 holds the trial file. An older report stopping at "nine-year sentence" misses the remand entirely. A conviction and a sentence ruling can sit side by side. The docket shows which one still moves. The court's search interface lists docket events and later documents. That results list is not the whole case file.
Note: Pull the written order from the docket before describing any changed sentence.
Colorado Morphew Pending Case
Barry Morphew's legal saga spans two counties. He was first busted in Chaffee County in May 2021. That case was dismissed without prejudice in April 2022. A grand jury reindicted him in 2025, and the matter now sits in Alamosa County District Court as case 2025CR128. The docket shows a not-guilty plea with the trial process still underway. Nothing is final. Because the case shifted after the first dismissal, check the live docket before relying on any summary.
The Colorado Judicial Branch case page is the right place to confirm current status. His 2021 booking photo traces to the Chaffee County Sheriff or the jail that received him. The present prosecution belongs to Alamosa County. Treat the dismissed first case and the pending second case as two separate proceedings.
Colorado Stauch Retrial Record
Letecia Stauch was convicted in 2023 in El Paso County District Court case 20CR1358. She received life without parole plus consecutive terms. On April 2, 2026, the Colorado Court of Appeals reversed the judgment and ordered a new trial. A biased juror had taken part in deliberations. The court also weighed one warrant challenge and rejected it. The 2026COA22 opinion states the reasoning in full. El Paso County holds the original custody and booking record. The case page and district-court file hold the complaint, filings, and orders. After a reversal, the old conviction is no longer the current disposition. Check later court activity before describing the retrial status. The Judicial Branch search locates case events and the appeal. The booking photo stays the same. The legal outcome underneath it keeps changing, which is exactly the point.
Use current court orders to explain a changed case status. An older charge page or image cannot do that work.
Look Up Any Colorado Arrest
An ordinary Colorado arrest record follows the same trail. Start with the county or arresting agency. Find the roster or booking report. Request the booking sheet or photo if it is not posted publicly. Then use the court docket to check the disposition. For older records, work out the State Archives series or the local retention schedule. The Colorado archives page lays out the historical request path.
- Confirm the name, county, approximate date, and likely booking agency.
- Check the county’s official roster or report and note its custody window and photo policy.
- Ask the records custodian for the exact booking record and any releasable image.
- Search the court docket, then request the final disposition or judgment from the court.
- If the case is sealed or expunged, use the current order and the correct agency or court process.
The Colorado Judicial Branch's Docket Search narrows a case by county and court. It also filters by case number, party, and date. Its online view is not a free document archive. The agency record, court record, and any archive copy each need a separate look. For history, the Colorado State Archives catalog also searches by agency, collection, county, date, and record type. A collection entry can describe a photo series without showing the images.
Identify a collection or call number in the catalog first. Then ask archives staff what it holds and how to request access. For a case that may have been sealed, the current court hub points to the correct petition and form type.
A court order is the key source for the legal effect of a case. It does not automatically erase every older news or archive copy.